We often get asked by some of our customers how they should know whether they need their roof repaired or replaced. That’s why we wanted to create a blog post that explains the choice of both options in a little more detail so that you’ll have a better idea of what’s best for your home.

Keep in mind that there are various factors when it comes to your roof. This article will simply guide you through your options so that you have the best possible understanding of them.

Replacement vs Repair: How Do They Differ?

The main difference between them is that repair is usually sufficient for fixing smaller issues with your roof, whereas for more significant problems, you’ll need a replacement. For example, if the tiles or slates of your roof are just a little torn and cracked, a repair may be enough.

However, if your roof has had more serious damage for whatever reason, or it’s simply too old, then a replacement is needed. Sometimes, homeowners also choose a replacement for personal preferences, despite a repair being sufficient. 

Replacements are more expensive, as there is a lot more labor and materials involved.

However, a replacement also has the following benefits:

  • You have a fresh roof that won’t need repairs any time soon
  • You’ll have a modern roof that is completely up-to-date with the newest building codes
  • It will give your property a stunning new look
  • The roof is more secure and reliable

Other Things To Consider Before Choosing

We also wanted to explain some other factors you should consider before choosing between a replacement and a repair.

Age of Roof – If your roof is very old, it may not be worth repairing it, as it might not have a lot of life left. Most roofs can last anywhere from 15 to 40 years, depending on the type of roof, materials, and a few other factors. If you feel that you are getting towards those time frames, it may be worth contacting us for a free consultation, and we can guide you from there.

How long you want to stay in your home – Another significant factor is how long you want to stay in your home. The reason being that if you do want to sell your home, then it will be quite hard to sell with a damaged or bad condition roof. So, in that case, it may be worth getting a roof replacement to improve the house’s overall value. On the other hand, it could also make sense to repair the roof, as you won’t be there for a long time, but it all depends on your exact scenario.

Budget – Lastly, it is also important to consider your budget. If you are looking for a budget-friendly solution and your home allows it, then a repair might be the best choice.

When Should You Get Which?

Now that we have covered the basics of a roof repair vs replacement let’s look at when which option is best suited.

When a Repair Is Suited

Here are some common signs that you need a roof repair:

  • If there are slight leaks
  • Nail Pops
  • If the shingles are cracked or missing
  • If it hasn’t been installed/maintained properly
  • Punctures and holes
  • Damage from trees
  • Shrinkage
  • If the weather has caused slight damage
  • If there have been problems with the ventilation
  • Air gun Nailing mistakes

When a Replacement Is Suited

Something important to note is that most of the time, a repair is just a temporary solution. If you would like a long-lasting option, then it’s best to go for the replacement.

Here are some more reasons why you might need a roof replacement. 

  • If the life of your current roof is coming to an end
  • If there has been some significant damage to your roof, such as from natural disasters
  • If your roof is not compliant with current building codes
  • If you would like a new roof 

Need More Help? – Get In Touch For a Free Consultation

That’s it! We hope you have enjoyed this article on how to know whether you need a roof replacement or repair. If you are still in doubt, contact us, and we’ll be happy to help you with a free consultation.

If you would like to read more on roofing, check out some of our related posts below. 

7 Signs Your Roof Needs To Be Repaired or Replaced

How To Inspect Your Roof For Potential Damage

Recommended Posts